First Overtime Game (T-OT-010)
1  12/4/1940 Chester Pros @ Philadelphia Seymour AA (2OT), playoff

Most History (T-OT-020)
12  Hyde Park Cowboys, 1977,78,2-81,82,83,95,97,98,3-99 (7W 5L)
12  Watertown Red & Black, 1976,77,78,81,83,84,90,91,2-92,97,02 (3W 5L 3T)
9  Johnstown Colonials 1974,79,80,87,90,92 (3),96 (5W 2L 2T)
8  Hudson Vikings, 2-1972,74,80,81,83,89,90 (4W 4L)
8  Middleboro Cobras, 1976,81,96,97,98,3-99 (3W 4L 1T)
8  Pierce County Bengals, 1992-2001 Northwest League (2W 5L 1T)
7  Norfolk Neptunes, 1965,66,67,68,2-70,71 (4W 3L)
7  Frederick Falcons, 1970,81,4-86,87 (5W 2L)
7  Worcester Mass Fury, 2008,09,10,11,13 (5W 2L)
6  Indianapolis Capitols, 1968,69,70,72,73,78 (4W 2L)
6  Glens Falls Greenjackets, 1976,82,84,86,87,90 (5W 1L)

Most Season (T-OT-030)
4  Frederick Falcons, 1986 (3W 1L)
4  Lockport Invaders, 1994 (2W 1L 1T)
3  Philadelphia Bulldogs, 1966 (3W)
3  Columbus Winds, 1977 Ohio League (3 T)
3  Johnstown, 1992 (2W 1L)
3  Detroit Downriver Raiders,1995 (3W)
3  Kalamazoo Tornadoes, 1995 (2W 1L)
3  Flint Falcons, 1995 (1W 2L)
3  Middleboro Cobras, 1999 (2W 1L)
3  Hyde Park Cowboys, 1999 (1W 2L)

Most OT Wins Season (T-OT-040)
3  Philadelphia Bulldogs, 1966
3  Frederick Falcons, 1986

Most OT Losses Season (T-OT-050)
3  Washington (DC) Metro Buccaneers, 1986

Best Won/Loss Percentage History (T-OT-060)
1.000  Philadelphia Bulldogs, 1963, 3-66 (4W 0L)
1.000  Youngstown Hardhats, 1972 2-79 (3W 0L)
1.000  San Jose Tigers, 1977,79,80 (3W 0L)

Worst Won/Loss Percentage History (T-OT-070)
.000  Skagit Valley Raiders, 2-1979,80,85 (0W 4L)
.000  Albany Metro-Mallers, 1977,83,87 (0W 3L)
.250  Baltimore Eagles, 1970,73,2-75 (1W 3L)
.250  Anderson Packers, 1979,80,2-84 (1W 3L)
.333  Hudson Vikings

Most Overtime Periods (T-OT-080)
5  Plymouth Rocks 20, Hyde Park Cowboys 19, 11/14/1977, playoff
5  Northwest Avalanche vs Pierce County Knights, 4/22/2006
4  Providence Kings 12, Marlboro Shamrocks 6, 10/1/1976
4  Tuscarawas County Bullets 26, Tri-County Warriors 23, 11/27/1999, championship

Most OT Games Between Two Teams (T-OT-090)
5  Hyde Park Cowboys vs. Middleboro Cobras, 1997,98,3-99

Most OT Games Between Two Teams Season (T-OT-100)
3  Hyde Park Cowboys vs. Middleboro Cobras, 1999